Skip to main content
Why Schools Do FBAs: The History Behind the IDEA Mandate
Research & Insights

Why Schools Do FBAs: The History Behind the IDEA Mandate

From exclusion-era discipline to Honig v. Doe and IDEA 1997: the legal history that made FBAs a civil-rights protection, not paperwork.

PsychTeacherAdminBCBA6 references1 resource
Back to Blog
Bobby Hillman
Bobby Hillman, M.Ed., LBA, BCBA
Founder, Classroom Pulse
August 11, 2026
8 min read

Best For

Teams this article is built to help

PsychTeacherAdminBCBA

Category: Research & Insights

Evidence

What backs this guide

6

Curated references are cited at the end of the article.

Materials

What you can leave with

3
  • Condensed key takeaways
  • 1 bonus download
  • Interactive self-check quiz
Share this article:

When an FBA lands on your to-do list, it can feel like one more compliance task in an already crowded year. But the functional behavior assessment requirement didn't come from an administrator's checklist. It came from a fifty-year legal struggle over whether students with disabilities could be pushed out of school for the very behaviors their disabilities produce. Understanding why the FBA mandate exists changes how you approach the work.

Before 1975: The Era of Exclusion

For most of the twentieth century, American public schools were under no obligation to educate children with disabilities. Many states had laws explicitly permitting schools to turn away students deemed "uneducable" or "disruptive." When Congress investigated the problem in the early 1970s, its findings were stark: roughly one million children with disabilities were excluded from public schools entirely, and more than half of those enrolled were not receiving services appropriate to their needs.

The Education for All Handicapped Children Act of 1975 (Public Law 94-142), renamed the Individuals with Disabilities Education Act, or IDEA, in 1990, changed the baseline. Every eligible child was now entitled to a free appropriate public education (FAPE) in the least restrictive environment, with an individualized education program and procedural safeguards for families.

Why This History Matters for Behavior

The 1975 law guaranteed access, but it said almost nothing about behavior. That silence created a gap: schools could no longer refuse to enroll a student with a disability, but they could still suspend or expel that student for behavior. For students whose disabilities affected behavior, exclusion didn't end in 1975. It just changed doors.

The Discipline Loophole

Between 1975 and the late 1980s, a pattern emerged that advocates came to call "exclusion through the back door." A student with an emotional or developmental disability would engage in challenging behavior, often behavior directly connected to the disability itself, and the school would respond with suspension, indefinite removal, or expulsion. The student had a legal right to be in school, but discipline procedures written for the general population offered a workaround.

The core tension was genuine, and it still is: schools must keep everyone safe, and schools must educate students whose disabilities include behavior that disrupts or alarms. What the law lacked was any framework for resolving that tension other than removal. There was no requirement to ask why the behavior was happening, no requirement to try function-based support before exclusion, and no meaningful check on repeated removals.

An Honest Note on the Era

It's worth acknowledging that the behavior-management practices of this period were often harsh by modern standards, both in schools and in clinical settings, including the use of aversive procedures that the field has since moved decisively away from. Autistic self-advocates continue to push the field on this history, and modern assent-based, trauma-informed practice is in part a response to it. Honest history is part of doing this work well.

Honig v. Doe (1988): The Turning Point

The collision reached the U.S. Supreme Court in Honig v. Doe (1988). The case involved two San Francisco students with emotional disabilities who had been indefinitely suspended, pending expulsion, for behavior the record connected to their disabilities. California argued that schools needed a "dangerousness exception" to the law's stay-put provision, the rule that a student remains in their current educational placement while disputes are resolved.

The Supreme Court said no. Congress had written the stay-put provision without exceptions, the Court held, precisely because of the history of schools unilaterally excluding students with disabilities. Schools retained real tools (short-term suspensions of up to ten school days, and the ability to seek a court order in genuinely dangerous situations), but they could not simply remove a student with a disability from school indefinitely because of disability-related behavior.

What Honig v. Doe Established

No unilateral long-term exclusion

Schools cannot use indefinite suspension or expulsion to remove a student with a disability for disability-related behavior while placement disputes are pending.

The ten-day framework

Short-term removals of up to ten school days remained available as a "cooling off" mechanism, a threshold that still structures discipline procedures today.

An unanswered question

If schools can't simply remove students for disability-related behavior, what are they supposed to do instead? The Court didn't say. Congress would answer nine years later.

IDEA 1997: The FBA Mandate Arrives

The 1997 amendments to IDEA were Congress's answer to the question Honig left open. For the first time, the terms "functional behavioral assessment" and "behavior intervention plan" appeared in federal special education law. The 1997 law did two big things for behavior:

  • 1. Discipline triggers. When a disciplinary removal amounts to a change of placement (generally, removals beyond the ten-day threshold), the team must address behavior through a functional behavioral assessment and a behavior intervention plan, and conduct a manifestation determination review to examine whether the behavior was linked to the student's disability.
  • 2. Proactive consideration. For any student whose behavior impedes their own learning or that of others, the IEP team must consider positive behavioral interventions, strategies, and supports, not just consequences.

The logic of the mandate was a direct repudiation of the exclusion era: before a school escalates removal, someone has to ask why the behavior is happening and build a plan that addresses that reason. The FBA is the structured way of asking. If you want a practical walkthrough of that process, our FBA data collection guide for special education teachers covers it step by step.

IDEA 2004: Refinements and Realities

The 2004 reauthorization (the Individuals with Disabilities Education Improvement Act) kept the FBA framework and refined how it operates in discipline situations:

  • A sharpened manifestation standard. The team asks whether the conduct was caused by, or had a direct and substantial relationship to, the student's disability, or was the direct result of the school's failure to implement the IEP.
  • FBA and BIP on manifestation. When behavior is a manifestation of disability, the team must conduct an FBA (unless one was already done) and implement or review a behavior intervention plan.
  • Special circumstances. For weapons, drugs, or serious bodily injury, schools may move a student to an interim alternative educational setting for up to forty-five school days regardless of manifestation, with services continuing.

What Federal Law Does NOT Specify

Notably, IDEA has never defined how to conduct an FBA. It does not prescribe methods, instruments, timelines for completion, or who must conduct the assessment. Those details live in state regulations, state education agency guidance, and professional practice standards, and they vary meaningfully from state to state. Some states require FBAs in situations federal law doesn't (for example, at initial consideration of certain interventions), and state timelines and triggers differ. Always check your own state's rules.

Why Congress Chose the FBA

The FBA wasn't invented in 1997. Congress borrowed it from behavior analysis, where the science was already mature. Iwata and colleagues' landmark 1982 work on the functional analysis of self-injury demonstrated experimentally that the same behavior could serve different functions in different individuals, and that identifying the function was the key to effective treatment. Carr and Durand's 1985 research on functional communication training showed that teaching a functionally equivalent communication skill could reduce problem behavior.

By the mid-1990s, decades of research pointed to the same conclusion: interventions matched to a behavior's function outperform interventions based on what the behavior looks like. When Congress needed a mechanism to replace exclusion with support, function-based assessment was the natural choice. If the function framework is new to you, start with our overview of the four functions of behavior with classroom examples.

What This Means for Practitioners Today

Seen against this history, the FBA is not paperwork. It is the mechanism Congress built to ensure that a student's disability-related behavior triggers understanding and support rather than exclusion. That reframe has practical consequences:

FBA as Civil-Rights Protection

A rushed, checkbox FBA fails the exact student the law was written to protect. The quality of the assessment is the substance of the protection: real data, a defensible function hypothesis, a plan matched to that function.

Don't Wait for the Trigger

Federal law requires an FBA in certain discipline situations, but nothing stops teams from conducting one proactively the moment behavior begins impeding learning. Early assessment is almost always better practice than crisis-driven assessment.

Families are part of this history too: parents were the plaintiffs who built the case law. If a family on your caseload asks about their rights, our parent's guide to requesting an FBA is a useful resource to share.

For teams, the operational challenge is honoring both the letter and the spirit of the mandate: collecting real ABC data instead of recollections, tracking assessment milestones against your state's timelines, and producing a plan someone can actually implement. Tools like Classroom Pulse can help by structuring ABC data collection and FBA interviews so the assessment rests on evidence rather than memory, but the professional judgment of your school psychologist, BCBA, or behavior specialist remains the heart of the process.

A Note on This Article

This article is general information about the history and structure of federal special education law, not legal advice. Federal requirements interact with state regulations that vary in their FBA triggers, timelines, and procedures. For questions about a specific student or situation, consult your district's special education director or legal counsel.

The Bottom Line

The FBA mandate exists because, for decades, students with disabilities were excluded from school for the very behaviors their disabilities produced. Honig v. Doe closed the exclusion loophole; IDEA 1997 and 2004 built the replacement: understand the behavior, then support it. Every well-conducted FBA honors that history.

Ready to run your next FBA on real data instead of recollection? Start collecting structured ABC data with Classroom Pulse.

References

Carr, E. G., & Durand, V. M. (1985). Reducing behavior problems through functional communication training. Journal of Applied Behavior Analysis, 18(2), 111–126.

Education for All Handicapped Children Act of 1975, Pub. L. No. 94-142.

Honig v. Doe, 484 U.S. 305 (1988).

Individuals with Disabilities Education Act Amendments of 1997, Pub. L. No. 105-17.

Individuals with Disabilities Education Improvement Act of 2004, Pub. L. No. 108-446.

Iwata, B. A., Dorsey, M. F., Slifer, K. J., Bauman, K. E., & Richman, G. S. (1982). Toward a functional analysis of self-injury. Analysis and Intervention in Developmental Disabilities, 2(1), 3–20. (Reprinted 1994, Journal of Applied Behavior Analysis, 27(2), 197–209.)

Put This Into Practice

Turn the article into action with ready-to-use materials. Downloads stay open; emailed resources and quiz results are opt-in.

Key Takeaways

  • Before 1975, schools could legally exclude children with disabilities; PL 94-142 guaranteed access but left behavior unaddressed
  • Honig v. Doe (1988) closed the discipline loophole: schools cannot unilaterally exclude students long-term for disability-related behavior
  • IDEA 1997 introduced the FBA/BIP requirement so removal is replaced by understanding why behavior occurs
  • IDEA 2004 refined manifestation determination but never defined FBA methodology; state triggers and timelines vary, so check your state's rules
  • A quality FBA is the substance of a civil-rights protection; teams can and should assess proactively rather than waiting for a discipline trigger

Bonus Materials

Clean downloads to pair with this article

Download resources directly or send a copy to your inbox. Marketing updates are optional.

1 ready-to-use download
PDF download

FBA Timeline Template

Plan and track FBA milestones and deadlines

Download now

Do You Know Why the FBA Mandate Exists?

Test your knowledge of the legal history behind the FBA requirement.

3 questions~2 min

For behavior specialists

Put this into practice with your own data

Log behaviors as they happen, see the pattern on a graph, and bring a clear summary to your next team meeting.

Start Your Next FBA on Real Data

Free for up to 3 students. No credit card required.

About the Author

Bobby Hillman
Bobby Hillman, M.Ed., LBA, BCBA
Founder, Classroom Pulse

Bobby Hillman is a Board Certified Behavior Analyst and Licensed Behavior Analyst with an M.Ed. in Special Education and more than 25 years in public special education and autism services. He works as a Behavior Instructional Specialist and founded Classroom Pulse to reduce the documentation load on classroom teams while keeping the detail FBA and BIP work requires.

About Classroom Pulse

Get More Insights Like This

One email on Fridays with the week's new articles. Unsubscribe anytime.

Stay updated with behavior tracking tips. Unsubscribe anytime. Privacy Policy.