
Best For
Teams this article is built to help
Category: Research & Insights
Evidence
What backs this guide
Curated references are cited at the end of the article.
Materials
What you can leave with
- Condensed key takeaways
- Interactive self-check quiz
If you learned about behavior analysis a generation ago, you might have been taught that the goal was compliance: reduce the behavior, reward the sitting-still, move on. That is not the field today, and the story of how it changed is worth knowing. It runs through a genuine scientific breakthrough, a genuinely uncomfortable history, sustained criticism from the autistic community that practitioners should take seriously, and a modern movement that treats assent, choice, and dignity as clinical variables, not afterthoughts.
Where It Began: The Operant Foundation
The scientific core of behavior analysis comes from B.F. Skinner's work on operant conditioning in the mid-twentieth century: behavior is shaped by its consequences, occurs in predictable relationship to its environment, and can be studied one organism at a time with careful measurement. Skinner's 1953 book Science and Human Behavior laid out the framework that still underpins every ABC chart and every reinforcement plan in use today.
Those principles were sound, and they still are. Reinforcement is real. Environment matters. Measurement beats guesswork. When researchers began applying these principles to socially important human problems in the 1960s, applied behavior analysis was born, and it produced real help for people who had been written off as unteachable.
The Principles vs. the Practices
A useful distinction for everything that follows: the principles of behavior (reinforcement, extinction, stimulus control) are descriptions of how learning works. The practices built on those principles (what goals we choose, what procedures we use, who gets a say) reflect the values of their era. The principles have held up. Some of the practices have not.
In those early decades, however, the dominant clinical question was essentially: how do we make this behavior stop? Interventions were often chosen by topography (what the behavior looked like) rather than by what it accomplished for the person. That framing is where the field's biggest scientific correction, and its biggest ethical failures, both live.
1982: The Question Changes
In 1982, Brian Iwata and colleagues published a study on the functional analysis of self-injurious behavior that quietly reorganized the entire field. Instead of asking "how do we stop it?", they asked "why does it happen?" Then they answered the question experimentally, systematically arranging conditions (attention, escape from demands, alone, play) and observing which ones the behavior tracked.
The finding that mattered: the same behavior served different functions for different people. One person's self-injury was maintained by escape from demands; another's by attention; another's by automatic reinforcement. Which means a single one-size-fits-all "treatment for self-injury" was never going to work: the intervention has to match the function.
Why This Still Matters in Schools
Every modern FBA descends from this shift: every ABC data sheet, every functional analysis, every hypothesis statement in a BIP. If your team has ever said "we can't pick an intervention until we know the function," you are living inside the 1982 turn. Its logic is also why ethical PBIS implementation insists on individualized, function-based support at Tier 3 rather than escalating consequences.
1985: Teaching Instead of Suppressing
Three years later, Edward Carr and V. Mark Durand took the next logical step. If behavior serves a function, if it is, in a real sense, communication, then the humane and effective intervention is not to suppress it but to teach a better way to get the same need met. Their 1985 work on Functional Communication Training (FCT) showed that teaching a student to request attention or help could reduce problem behavior, with the emphasis on teaching a replacement rather than suppressing the behavior.
The Old Frame
Behavior is a problem to eliminate. Success = the behavior stops. The student's need behind the behavior is not part of the plan.
The FCT Frame
Behavior is communication about an unmet need. Success = the student has a reliable, easier, socially workable way to meet that need, and the old behavior becomes unnecessary.
FCT reframed the practitioner's job from behavior reduction to skill construction. It is one of the most replicated findings in the applied literature, and it is the intellectual ancestor of every "replacement behavior" line in every BIP your team has ever written.
The History the Field Has to Own
Here is the part that professional training programs sometimes skip, and shouldn't.
Early applied work, including some of the foundational autism intervention research of the 1960s and 1970s, used aversive procedures: contingent electric shock, slapping, shouting, forced compliance. These were published, defended, and taught. Aversives declined sharply as reinforcement-based alternatives proved effective, but they did not vanish; the use of contingent electric skin shock persisted at a small number of facilities into the present era, and behavior-analytic professional organizations have since formally opposed the practice. That opposition is recent enough that it should temper any impulse toward self-congratulation.
Separately, and this criticism applies to reinforcement-based practice too, many autistic adults who experienced intensive behavioral intervention as children have described it as harmful. The autistic self-advocacy community has sustained serious criticism of compliance-focused practice for decades: goals like eye contact and "quiet hands" that prioritized looking typical over feeling safe; hour counts that consumed childhoods; suppression of harmless self-regulatory behavior like stimming; and programs where a child's "no" was treated as noncompliance to overcome rather than communication to honor. Some describe long-term consequences, including masking and anxiety, that they attribute to years of being taught that their instincts were wrong.
This Conversation Is Not Settled
Practitioners sometimes respond that these criticisms describe outdated practice. That response is too easy. The criticism is ongoing, it comes from the population the field exists to serve, and compliance-focused practice has not disappeared from every classroom or clinic. The professionally serious posture is to know this critique well, listen to autistic voices directly rather than through summaries, and treat "would the student endorse this goal?" as a live clinical question, not to declare the debate resolved.
None of this erases the people genuinely helped by function-based, reinforcement-based intervention, including students who gained communication, safety, and access to their own lives. Both things are true. A field confident in its science can afford an honest accounting of its history.
The Modern Response: Assent, PFA, and Compassionate Care
The best of contemporary practice is best understood as a response to that history: an attempt to keep the science while rebuilding the values around it.
Assent-Based Practice
Modern ethics codes distinguish consent (from the guardian) from assent (the student's own ongoing willingness), and increasingly treat withdrawal of assent (pulling away, protesting, shutting down) as data that should change what the adult does next. A student's "no" is information about the intervention, not a behavior to extinguish. Our guide to consent and assent in behavior interventions walks through what this looks like procedurally for school teams.
Hanley's PFA/IISCA and "Today's ABA"
Gregory Hanley's practical functional assessment (PFA) and the interview-informed synthesized contingency analysis (IISCA) rebuilt the functional analysis itself around safety and rapport: start from an open-ended interview with people who know the student, synthesize the likely contingencies rather than testing them in isolation, keep the analysis brief, and, critically, establish a context where the student is happy, relaxed, and engaged before any demands are introduced. Treatment built on this foundation leans on skill-based instruction: communication, toleration, and cooperation taught in that order, with the student's assent monitored throughout. Hanley has framed this explicitly as "today's ABA," a deliberate break from compliance-first practice.
Trauma-Informed and Compassionate Care
In parallel, the field has begun integrating what educators already know from trauma-informed behavior approaches: many students with intensive behavior needs have trauma histories, escalation procedures can re-traumatize, and felt safety is a prerequisite for learning, not a reward for compliance. Recent behavior-analytic literature on trauma-informed practice and on compassionate care has pushed rapport, relationship quality, and caregiver collaboration from "soft skills" into the clinical model itself.
What Changed, In One Table
The question
"How do we stop it?" → "Why does it happen, and what skill meets that need?"
The student's "no"
Noncompliance to work through → assent withdrawal that changes the plan
Success
Behavior suppressed → need met through a skill the student can actually use, in a context they would choose
What This Means Monday Morning
For a school team, forty years of field evolution reduces to a few operating rules:
- 1 Function before intervention. No consequence plan, no replacement behavior, no goal until the team has real data on why the behavior happens. Structured ABC data collection and indirect assessments exist precisely so this step is doable in a real classroom.
- 2 Assent matters. Build the student's willingness into the plan: document how the team will recognize assent withdrawal and what the adults will do differently when it happens.
- 3 Replacement skills over suppression. If a BIP reduces a behavior without teaching a functionally equivalent skill, it is incomplete. Ask what the student gets to do instead, and whether they would choose it.
- 4 Audit goals for whose comfort they serve. Eye contact, "quiet hands," sitting perfectly still: if a goal exists to make a student look typical rather than to expand their access, autonomy, or safety, it deserves a hard second look with the family and, wherever possible, the student.
- 5 Know the critique. When a parent arrives having read autistic adults' accounts of harmful ABA, the credible response is not defensiveness. It is demonstrating, in your documents and your practice, that this team runs on function, assent, and skills.
Tools can support this shift (platforms like Classroom Pulse structure FBA data collection and function-based BIP drafting so the "why" step is never skipped), but the shift itself is a matter of professional values. AI-assisted or not, every hypothesis and every plan still requires review by a qualified professional, and every plan still answers to the student living under it.
The Bottom Line
Behavior analysis changed because its own science demanded it: functional analysis made suppression-first practice indefensible, FCT made teaching the obvious alternative, and the people the field serves insisted, and continue to insist, that dignity is not optional. The honest version of this history makes practitioners better, not worse, at defending their work.
If your team is ready to make assent concrete rather than aspirational, start with documentation that builds it into every plan.
References
Skinner, B. F. (1953). Science and human behavior. Macmillan.
Iwata, B. A., Dorsey, M. F., Slifer, K. J., Bauman, K. E., & Richman, G. S. (1982). Toward a functional analysis of self-injury. Analysis and Intervention in Developmental Disabilities, 2(1), 3–20. (Reprinted 1994 in the Journal of Applied Behavior Analysis, 27(2), 197–209.)
Carr, E. G., & Durand, V. M. (1985). Reducing behavior problems through functional communication training. Journal of Applied Behavior Analysis, 18(2), 111–126.
Hanley, G. P., Jin, C. S., Vanselow, N. R., & Hanratty, L. A. (2014). Producing meaningful improvements in problem behavior of children with autism via synthesized analyses and treatments. Journal of Applied Behavior Analysis, 47(1), 16–36.
Taylor, B. A., LeBlanc, L. A., & Nosik, M. R. (2019). Compassionate care in behavior analytic treatment: Can outcomes be enhanced by attending to relationships with caregivers? Behavior Analysis in Practice, 12(3), 654–666.
Put This Into Practice
Turn the article into action with ready-to-use materials. Downloads stay open; emailed resources and quiz results are opt-in.
Key Takeaways
- Iwata et al. (1982) shifted the field's core question from 'how do we stop it' to 'why does it happen'
- Carr & Durand's FCT (1985) reframed intervention as teaching a skill that meets the same need, not suppressing behavior
- The field's history includes aversive procedures, and ongoing criticism from the autistic self-advocacy community deserves serious engagement, not dismissal
- Modern practice treats assent, choice, and dignity as clinical variables; Hanley's PFA/IISCA and compassionate-care models build them in
- Monday morning: function before intervention, monitor assent withdrawal, and choose replacement skills the student would actually choose
How Well Do You Know the Field's Evolution?
Check your understanding of how behavior analysis moved from compliance-focused practice to assent-based, compassionate care.
Tags:
For behavior specialists
Put this into practice with your own data
Log behaviors as they happen, see the pattern on a graph, and bring a clear summary to your next team meeting.
Build Function-Based PlansFree for up to 3 students. No credit card required.
About the Author

Bobby Hillman is a Board Certified Behavior Analyst and Licensed Behavior Analyst with an M.Ed. in Special Education and more than 25 years in public special education and autism services. He works as a Behavior Instructional Specialist and founded Classroom Pulse to reduce the documentation load on classroom teams while keeping the detail FBA and BIP work requires.
About Classroom PulseRelated Articles
Why Schools Do FBAs: The History Behind the IDEA Mandate
From exclusion-era discipline to Honig v. Doe and IDEA 1997: the legal history that made FBAs a civil-rights protection, not paperwork.
Pharmacology and Behavior Data: What Schools Can Track
Document medication-related behavior patterns objectively while keeping medical decisions with families and licensed providers.
Functional Analysis in Schools: When FBA Needs Clarity
Know when descriptive FBA is not enough and what safeguards teams need before considering functional analysis procedures.
